Skip to content
Join the newsletter
Menu

Home & Kitchen

What to check before buying new bed sheets

A good sheet deal starts with the right fit and feel. Here's how to check the label, the set and the final cost before you buy.

Measuring tape at the edge of a mattress beside a folded sheet and fabric swatches.
In this guide
  1. Measure your mattress, topper included
  2. Read the fiber label beyond the buzzwords
  3. Choose your weave, then check thread count
  4. Check care instructions and certifications
  5. Size up the set, total cost and return policy
  6. Spot it: your sheet-shopping checklist

Before you get distracted by a lofty thread count or a pretty package, check three things: Will the sheets fit your bed, feel good to you and work with your laundry routine? Then look at what's included and what you'll pay at checkout.

You don't need to become a fabric detective. A tape measure, a few label checks and a quick read of the return policy can help you narrow the field.

Measure your mattress, topper included

Start with the bed you have, not just the size name you remember. Measure its width, length and depth in inches. If you use a mattress topper, leave it on when you measure the height.

Compare those numbers with the fitted sheet's measurements. Labels such as “queen” and “deep pocket” can vary by retailer, so the actual dimensions are more useful than the name alone. The research recommends a fitted-sheet pocket at least 2 inches deeper than the mattress height.

Check how the sheet stays in place, too. Elastic around the full edge or straps can help it grip. If the listing skips the pocket depth, look for the full specifications or ask the seller before ordering.

Read the fiber label beyond the buzzwords

“Premium” sounds nice, but it doesn't tell you what you're sleeping on. Look for the fiber content on the package or product page. Is it all one fiber or a blend? If it's a blend, are the materials and their amounts clear?

For cotton, you may see long-staple or extra-long-staple varieties, including Pima and Supima. These can offer softness, strength and durability compared with short-staple cotton. Linen is another option to consider if breathability matters to you.

For sheets advertised with bamboo or eucalyptus, read the actual fiber label as well as the front of the package. If the details aren't clear, ask for them. Choose the material and feel you want rather than paying extra for a name you can't verify.

Choose your weave, then check thread count

Fiber is only part of the feel. The weave matters, too. Percale has a crisp, matte feel, while sateen has a smoother, silkier drape and may feel warmer. Think about which sounds better for your bed. If you can feel a sample before buying, even better.

Now for the number on the front. Thread count measures yarns per square inch, but a bigger number isn't enough on its own to judge a sheet. Counts can be inflated through the use of multi-ply yarns. Look at the fiber and weave alongside the count, and check whether the listing explains the yarn.

If a listing leads with a huge thread count but gives you little else to go on, keep looking for the details. Your favorite feel is more useful than a number you can't put in context.

Check care instructions and certifications

Picture laundry day before you buy. Can you machine-wash and dry the sheets the way you prefer? Does the label call for a setting you're willing to use? Read the care instructions on the listing or package, and check any information about shrinkage.

Certifications can give you another detail to check. OEKO-TEX Standard 100 relates to testing for harmful substances, while GOTS addresses organic materials and production practices. Read what a certification covers instead of treating a logo as a promise about every feature.

You may also see fabric weight listed as GSM, or grams per square meter. It's a weight measure, not a shortcut to your favorite feel. If a listing provides it, use it as one detail alongside the fiber and weave.

Size up the set, total cost and return policy

Before comparing two sets, check what's in each package. Does each include a fitted sheet, a flat sheet and pillowcases? How many pillowcases, and what size are they? If you need extra pieces, include those in your comparison.

At checkout, look beyond the item price. Review shipping, taxes and any other listed charges. Compare the final totals for sets that meet your needs, rather than assuming the lowest starting price is the best fit.

Finally, read the return policy. Check the return window, whether you can open or wash the sheets before returning them, and whether any return shipping or fees apply. Save the policy and your order details so you can find them if the fit or feel isn't right.

Spot it: your sheet-shopping checklist

  • Measure the mattress with your topper in place; compare all dimensions and pocket depth.
  • Read the fiber label, not just the claims on the front.
  • Pick a weave for the feel you like, then consider thread count.
  • Check care instructions and what any certification covers.
  • Confirm the pieces included, final cost and return terms.

Sources

  1. hometosight.com · /guide-to-buying-bed-sheets
  2. www.brooklinen.com · /blogs/education-center/the-sheet-buying-guide-everything-you-need-to-know-before-you-buy
  3. www.idealtextiles.co.uk · /blogs/inspiration/bed-sheets-four-step-label-check
  4. www.consumerreports.org · /home-garden/sheets/buying-guide
  5. theplainthread.com · /learn/how-to-choose-bed-sheets
  6. www.mattressnut.com · /how-to-buy-sheets
  7. www.goodhousekeeping.com · /what-to-buy/a70737425/bed-sheets-shopping-guide
  8. bulkcotton.com · /how-to-choose-bed-sheets
  9. wellwhisk.com · /best-all-around-elastic-fitted-sheets
  10. hjepl.com · /guides/what-gsm-should-linen-bed-sheets-be