How to choose a printer without overlooking ink costs
A printer’s purchase price is only part of the picture. Use your page count, color needs and supply costs to find a better fit.

In this guide
Look past the printer’s price tag and check what it will cost to keep printing. A model that fits your page count and color needs may be a better deal than one with a tempting upfront price.
The quick check: estimate how much you print, compare the cost per page, then add supplies to the purchase price. A little math now can help you avoid a printer that feels like a bargain only until the ink runs out.
Start with your page count and color needs
Think about a typical month, not your busiest printing week. Do you mostly print school forms and return labels, or do you also want color pictures and projects? Your answers give you a starting point for comparing supplies.
- Estimate the number of pages you print in a month.
- Split that estimate into black-and-white pages and color pages.
- Note whether you print regularly or leave the printer idle for long stretches.
- List the features you need, such as scanning, copying or printing on both sides.
Your estimate doesn’t have to be perfect. If your printing changes during the year, try a low and a high estimate when you compare costs. That gives you a range instead of one number to bet on.
Compare cartridge, ink tank and laser printers
Each type has a different supply setup. There’s no need to pick a winner before you know what you print.
- Cartridge inkjets use replaceable ink cartridges. Check both black and color costs for the model you’re considering.
- Ink tank printers use ink bottles to refill tanks. They can have a lower ink cost per page, which is worth checking if you print regularly or use color.
- Laser printers use toner. A monochrome model prints in black and white; a color laser can handle color too. Toner does not dry out, which may matter if your printer sits idle.
Compare actual models, not just categories. Supply costs vary, so the type of printer is a clue—not the final answer.
Calculate the cost per page
Cost per page tells you how much ink or toner is estimated to cost for each printed page. Find the current supply price and the manufacturer’s rated page yield—the estimated number of pages the supply can print. Then divide price by yield.
For black printing, use the black supply’s price and yield. For color, check how the manufacturer reports its color yield and which supplies are included. Use the same method for each printer so you’re comparing like with like.
Treat the result as an estimate, not a promise about your next page. It’s a way to compare supplies; it isn’t the full cost of owning the printer. Keep the printer price and other costs in your longer-term calculation.
Add up the printer and supply costs over time
Pick a time frame, such as two years, and use the same one for every model. Multiply your estimated black-and-white pages by the black cost per page. Do the same for your color pages and the color estimate. Add those amounts to the printer’s purchase price.
That gives you a useful estimate, not an exact checkout total. Check what supplies come in the box and add any other expected costs, such as paper. If you print much more or less than expected, run the numbers again.
The result might change which printer looks like the better deal. A lower purchase price doesn’t tell you what you’ll spend on supplies over time.
Check starter ink, refill sizes and compatible supplies
Before you choose, find out exactly what’s included in the box and its rated yield. Then check the price and yield of replacement supplies. Don’t assume the included ink will print the same number of pages as a replacement.
Compare standard and high-yield options using cost per page, not just the price of the pack. For a tank printer, check the refill bottles and their yields. Use current prices for the specific supplies that fit the printer.
You can also check compatible or remanufactured supplies alongside the printer maker’s own supplies. These can cost less, but compare the stated yield as well as the price. Check that the supply is listed for your exact printer model before including it in your math.
Size up ink subscriptions and plan limits
A supply subscription is another option to compare, not an automatic shortcut to a lower bill. Its value depends on the plan and how much you print. Extra-page charges can change the math, and buying supplies separately may work out better for some printing habits.
Read the plan details with your monthly page estimate handy. Ask:
- How many pages are included, and what happens if you go over?
- Do unused pages carry over, and are there limits?
- Can you change or cancel the plan, and what happens to the supplies if you do?
- How does the total compare with buying the supplies you’d otherwise use?
Run the comparison for a quiet month and a busy one. If your printing varies, look closely at how the plan handles both.
Spot it: your printer deal checklist
- Estimate your monthly black-and-white and color pages.
- Compare the printer types and features that fit your needs.
- Divide supply price by rated yield to estimate cost per page.
- Add the printer and estimated supply costs over the same time frame.
- Check included supplies, replacement sizes and compatibility.
- Read subscription limits and compare the plan with buying supplies separately.
Sources
- castleink.com · /blogs/printer-help/printer-ink-cost-calculator-see-what-your-printer-really-costs-per-page
- selectra.co.uk · /mobile/news/printer-cost-per-page-inkjet-versus-laser
- www.swiftink.com · /blog/printer-cost-per-page-calculator
- www.swiftink.com · /blog/laser-vs-inkjet-printer
- www.star-toner.com · /en/blogs/news/printer-with-cheapest-ink
- castleink.com · /pages/printer-ink-price-index
- www.consumerreports.org · /electronics-computers/printers/are-printer-ink-subscriptions-worth-it-a4050339657
- castleink.com · /blogs/printer-help/hp-instant-ink-vs-compatible-cartridges-the-real-cost-math-for-2026